Quantcast

12 thoughts on “Is it all over for Aiden McGeady and Celtic?”

  1. Can’t say I’ll be sorry to see him go…..
    Potential is enormous….doesn’t fulfill it…
    we, like every other club, need money….and if he’s one of the sources for big income….so be it….I wish him well if he leaves.

  2. I would have to agree,if only for his own development as a player.Aiden has never been given the protection by referee’s,infact he has consistantly been singled out by referee’s when he complains about the treatment dished out to him by defenders,look no futher than this seasons Celtic v Rangers to prove this point. McGeady has also had to indure vile and bigoted abuse from almost every SPL ground because of his preferred nationality.
    McGeady must now look to pastures new. Maybe not as far as Moscow,but most EPL don’t have the kind of cash the Hoops would require,so what ever Aiden decides i’m sure .
    all Hoops fans will wish him well.
    Hail Hail

  3. Every player has their price and McGeady isn’t any different. My own feeling is that he flatters to decieve more often than he delivers.
    McGinn if he stays injury free probibly carries as much if not more of a goal threat so would have a ready made replacement. This would allow any transfer fee recieved to be used where the team needs it most – striker and central defence.
    Like Mike tho wish him all the best.
    Hail Hail

  4. 90% plus would want to see mcgeady stay ??? are you having a laugh, i would say its the other way round. he plays well one in ten games and as you say he has no end product and if he is so good why is he only a sub for ireland.
    take the money and run .

  5. Although I’d be sorry to see him leave, I feel there could be someone special waiting to replace him. Not enough for me to put the brilliant tag around his neck. He was at times, but not often enough and rarely troubled Rangers.The money will come in handy and like Pete, I have a lot of time for McGinn. Maybe Strachan will take him as he’s been a great dressing room influence!

  6. Another pointless story that restates what we all know. Aiden McGeady to grow, must leave Celtic. Thats the worst kept secret in Scottish football.
    If a club meets or exceeds Celtic’s valuation then Aiden will be gone.

    As for Mark Guidi, even a broken clock is right twice a day. I find using the terms “journalist” and “reputation” laughable in regards to him

  7. No journalist, just like football managers, has a 100% record.

    The same reporter broke the story of McGeady criticising Dougie McDonald after the February derby match with a quote that McDonald wasn’t impartial.

    http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/football/spl/celtic/2010/03/07/dougie-mcdonald-was-biased-against-celtic-in-old-firm-clash-insists-aiden-mcgeady-86908-22091756/

    We’re all capable of making up our own minds and judging stories, the source of this story suggests that there is substance behind it.

  8. All we ever hear from to many so called supporters is that McGeady “flatters to deceive” or “no end product” (jesus, how original). Complete rubbish. If we had half decent strikers Aiden would have a much higher assist rate. Aiden McGeady is without a shadow of a doubt the best player in Scottish football. We will miss him when/if he leaves but then the greatest fans in the world will pick on someone else to aim their vitriol.

  9. If there is any truth in this it wil be one of the 1% of rumours that the Sunday Mail in general and Mark Guidi in particular has managed to get right.

    However, I would not shed any tears if McGeady did move.

    Although he has shown flashes of talent, consistency in his play has been missing, and it was only under Gordon Strachan who kept a short rein on him that he showed his best form.

    Tony Mowbray seemed to play him every week regardless of how he was performing, and last season he wasn’t performing all that often.

    There is good reason the player has been nicknamed Greedy McGeady.

    More interested in himself than in how he could enhance the overall performance of the team.

Comments are closed.