Latest News

Video: Watch the 95th minute penalty that Alan Muir refused to give Celtic

Image for Video: Watch the 95th minute penalty that Alan Muir refused to give Celtic

Alan Muir does have a bit of history when it comes to Celtic and handball incidents in the penalty area.

In 2015 Steven McLean took most of the blame in the aftermath of the Scottish Cup semi-final between Celtic and Inverness Caley Thistle when Josh Meekings clearly handled a header from Leigh Griffiths at Hampden.

As the stadium waited for the penalty and red card McLean saw nothing and neither did his perfectly placed additional assistant, Muir. Play on was the joint verdict as the football world, outside of Celtic looked in and laughed at an incident that would have shamed a banana republic.

To be fair, last night was darker, the incident happened at a far higher pace but handball, or use of the arm remains the same.

Callum McGregor had a split second, saw his chance and shot at goal. We have all seen a variety of penalty awards given in recent years and wondered about them but from around eight yards away a Ross County player raised his arm to elbow the shot away from goal.

Penalty. It was clear and obvious. Muir was perfectly placed to see it, the way that the ball struck the player there was only one conclusion, it wasn’t off his body or head, it struck an elbow.

No penalty from Muir but a corner. Fortunately, eventually from the corner Tom Rogic crossed for Tony Ralston to head the winner, the referee was spared further scrutiny.

Perhaps if Kris Boyd and Robbie Neilson make enough noise we will get an explanation from Crawford Allan on Radio Scotland on Saturday.

Share this article

Online and independent- the only way to be. Enjoying instant news access and reaction, following the trends if not an influencer!


  • Jim says:

    Never a penalty. His arm is next to his body. To put that near the hampden penalty is utter nonsense. Don’t know if my nerves could stand another finish like that one. Thank god for Tony Ralston. He has turned a lot of fans, including my own, opinion around completely. The fact that he is a good bloke makes it all the better.

  • Jim says:

    As clear a penalty as you will see. Arm in an unnatural position
    Raised to head height to block it. As we know Alan Muir has a problem
    Giving handball penalties to Celtic

  • Thomas Cochrane says:

    Anyone who says no penalty ????? What’s the soup of the day, get a grip !

  • Jim Duffy says:

    Our board should be calling this out,not so much the dubious decisions but they way our players are treated as the employer’s they have a duty for the safety and well-being of their work force ie the players but they do nothing,refs do not protect our players some one is going to end up crippled or put out of the game.but our board is complicit in skulduggery with the crooked bigoted SFA.

Comments are closed.