Latest News

Balanced themselves out- BBC pundit highlights the decision that denied Celtic a 3-0 lead

Image for Balanced themselves out- BBC pundit highlights the decision that denied Celtic a 3-0 lead

Michael Stewart has highlighted the first half ‘goal’ from Jota at Aberdeen last night which seems to have been overlooked in most of the post match analysis. 

Taking their lead from the howls of the Aberdeen players Celtic’s third goal has been thoroughly examined to try and find a reason to disallow it, either for offside or an obstruction on David Bates. 

Both arguments have limited merit whereas the first Aberdeen goal seems to be escaping scrutiny. After Mattie Kennedy had fired a shot wide of the post Willie Collum decided to take play back for a free kick at the side of the penalty box. 

When the ball was delivered Scott Brown held Carl Starfelt back from attempting to block Christian Ramirez’s shot. Collum never noticed the infringement and it was game on. 

Discussing the match on Sportscene last night the Sun reports Stewart saying: 

You’ve got to say credit to Celtic for getting themselves back in front but there is a huge element of controversy. I do think Liel Abada is in an offside position and he affects the game. 

Celtic let themselves down and let Aberdeen into the game. If you look right across the line here, you can see Abada is offside. 

When the ball comes back into the box, he blocks David Bates from getting back to challenge Jota. I do think if Abada isn’t there then Bates would have been able to challenge and maybe flick the ball away. It’s good play from Celtic to react so quickly but I don’t think the goal should have stood. 

There was one in the first half though when Jota was flagged offside when he went and knocked the ball past the goalkeeper.  I think he was probably onside in that one so perhaps they have balanced themselves out in that game but you can understand why Aberdeen were raging at that moment. 

With Celtic leading 2-0 Jota ran in behind the Dons defence with the flag going up as he prepared to face Gary Woods. The Dons keeper switched off when he saw the offside flag as Jota put the ball in the net, that incident seems to have avoided the level of scrutiny given to Celtic’s third goal. 

Share this article

Online and independent- the only way to be. Enjoying instant news access and reaction, following the trends if not an influencer!


  • Charlie dee says:

    3 points earned let them stew in it the stats show Celtic won 3-2 move on end of story

  • Pan says:

    No I cannot understand why Aberdeen were raging.

    The goal was perfectly good.

    So was the one that was chalked off, which would have made it 3-0 to Celtic.

    This referee is one of the poorest in Scotland and Aberdeen got the benefit of his poor refereeing throughout the game.

    Most Scottish referees think they are dealing with schoolboys. I taught for many years and never ever treated my pupils like these so called officials treat players. They don’t deserve respect as they show no respect. How dare they treat professional people like dirt. I got the best out of pupils because

    I treated them with respect and I earned their respect in turn. Our so called top Scottish referees are the worst on the planet. There are good ones but they are not allowed to officiate the big games, because they are too honest and are outside the Lanarkshire cabal.

    Lanarkshire and Glasgow is a hotbed of bigotry and the referees are all involved. Where else in the world would you have a supporters group from a Bellshill pub name their group after a Sevco supporting referee ((Beaton).

    The time is coming for legal action as the whole process is CORRUPT TO ITS CORE. Legal action would put the cat amongst the pigeons as these people have a duty of care and are not carrying that duty out.

    What we want is impartiality, nothing more.

Comments are closed.