Celtic have made another early exit from the SFA Youth Cup, losing 3-2 to St Mirren at the Third Round stage on Monday night.
The only consolation to take from the result was that it was played at Celtic’s new Barrowfield Training Complex.
In the two previous seasons Celtic lost out to Morton at the Second Round stage and Montrose at the Third Round in 2023 as holders of the competition.
When Michael Nicholson was asked at the 2024 AGM about lessons to be learned from the Montrose and Morton Academies he couldn’t see the connection.
Clearly there are deep rooted problems throughout the Celtic Academy that won’t be solved by the construction of a training complex.
LOWLAND LEAGUE
A look at the Lowland League table shows Celtic sitting in 12th place out of 18 in the 5th/6th tier of Scottish football.
A record of 4 wins, 5 draws and 4 defeats seems an accurate reflection of the ability of the squad which has a goal difference of For 26, Against 30.
Clydebank, promoted from the West of Scotland league during the summer are at the top of the table, nine points ahead of Bonnyrigg Rose who lost out to East Kilbride in the play-off
Five Celtic players are out on loan at Partick Thistle and Ayr United but it remains a huge leap to go from that level to pushing for a place in the first team.
FAILING ACADEMY
Paul Tisdale and Shaun Maloney are charged with creating a pathway from the Academy to the first team but it is 10 years on since Kieran Tierney took that step.
Tony Ralston, Stephen Welsh and Mikey Johnston have made contributions to the first team but none of them have been able to retain a place in the Starting XI for more than a handful of games.
Celtic provide a results only service for the B team on their website, no information is provided about the u-19 side.
The SFA website has the score-line for Youth Cup tie.
In the CAS Elite u-19 league Celtic have taken one point from two matches. With just eight teams playing each other twice it is unlikely that playing 14 league matches will develop any top talents.
Who should be removed first from Celtic?
Nicholson- a void of leadership
Rodgers- delivering success against the odds


On another point:
Dear Brendan and our players, please note that our supporters are solidly behind you all as we navigate these stormy waters at CP, caused by the board of the plc and ONE shareholder degrading our FC.
The football however, is not football The Celtic Way.
In the circumstances, most of us will get over a poor result tonight if it helps bring the inevitable end to the board’s residence at CP. All of them!
But let’s get fukkin real now. If you can’t get the team to perform and the team can’t get the team to perform on Sunday, and get 3 points from them diet hun, orange bastards in Edinburgh then there may well be unpleasant consequences. We might even cross you off our xmas card list! 🙂
Understand us, we’re ALWAYS on your side but we pay for and expect to be entertained and to win football matches leading up to lifting the title. That’s YOUR job, don’t let us down.
HH, SACK THE BOARD!! (if they cannae spell resoignashin, quit will do fine!)
PS, in the poll you have, just WTF are the 11%? Ah, got it. Your correctly named Celtic Thick News clowns trying to troll us on here.
I am sick of the post champions league exit transfer spending, and i think we all want the same thing with the board…. But….
1. Even if the protests are only affecting the players by tiny margins, is that then ok if we lose the league by a tiny margin? Is it worth it??
2. Is it ok if we blow the chance to rack up 9 or 10 in a row because the players might be affected by protests, is it not insane to even remotely risk that by self harm.
3. Do you think the smsm are playing celtic fans like fiddles and turning them against one another
4. Dont buy merch, dont buy burgers, programmes, most of all football tops, all of the above, but dont protest when our team needs all the positivity it can get.
Incidentally, if all celtic fans didnt buy tops for one season, it would have a huge impact on the board!
Im so dissapointed that our fan base is doing anything that even remotely negatively affects our team…. Who does that serve most??
Using the term snowflakes, is on a par with telling someone with mental health issues to man up. I think you are wrong, maybd strong willed, but not everyone is, and if the protests affect them by tiny margins, YOU are damaging our team.
Support the team, starve the board, but do us a favour and keep them separate!
HH
Editor: Another new contributor from the Celtic Thick News faction. Keeping a close eye on you lot, strange how your heroes as CEO and Chairman never get a mention. NOT ANOTHER PENNY.
My sole interest is our team, i am sick of the board, their transfer timing, and there project players, from downsizing after seville to not replacing Kyogo despite having a years heads up.
As for your mention of other websites, i can assure you that you are wrong, and if you can read my ramblings and arrive at the conclusion that the board are my heroes, sadly your anger is blinding you, a bit like my ex wife when she realised she wasn’t getting a 90-10 split in her favour.
Boards come and go, and they will eventually go, but our results cant be corrected, every point we drop, the jammed farts step further away.
Im just a fan who see’s results edging towards us losing games, confidence, cups and leagues.
Step back Joe, your rightly placed anger at the board is in danger of making you lose sight of where you want our club to be at the end of the season.
If all of us dont buy one single football top, the pressure will start bearing down on the board from their biggest sponsors, and it will lead to change
Sack the board, back the team
Editor: Still unable to mention Nicholson or Lawwell.
The youths now, The Women, The B Team, The main team…
What the fuck is happening to our Celtic !
Ive been a daily reader of your site for years, im afraid, youve just lost me as a reader with your irrational crap.
Im gona go read lawwells mates website, at least the guy is rational.
Good luck with your crusade, just hope the protests dont mess up us winning 10 in a row
How would you improve the youth/B team Joe? My instict would to have some big 24 team youth league champions league style to play throughout the season against the similar level youth teams with maybe a head hunted elite youth coach taking charge rather than ex player. I also think we should be using the league cup to develop young players similar to arsenal’s approach under wenger? So many good young players wasted with the current approach.
Editor: A new set of coaches would be a start. Players out of the Academy should get half a season in the Lowland League then sent on a well placed loan to clubs in Scotland. If they show up well they progress up the ladder.
Playing a full season in the Lowland League is a killer.
Celtic had a half hearted relationship with Admira Wacker for two seasons then abandoned it. Meaningful tie ups need to be made with clubs, players could go out to League of Ireland clubs to experience a full time set up and benefit from a February to November season then come back to be assessed.
The current set up is geared to fail. It needs completely dismantled.
Further down the Lennoxtown set up and St Ninian’s set up isn’t working.
Speaking to Aaron Hickey and Lennon Miller would certainly help.
My opinion is that we should go back to the great Jock Stein way of bringing young players into the team, when we had a reserve league and he gave each person showing talent a start in the first team, one at a time. It brings in young players and supports them to enable development and progress. I will also add that the wee Jock monicker is from my height and my protestant upbringing, I wouldn’t dream of being down the the great man’s name. Let’s sort this, sack the board. support the team, not a penny more. Let’s go further and donate what we would spend to local charities.