3rd June 2023; Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland: Scottish Cup Football Final, Celtic versus Inverness Caledonian Thistle; Peter Lawwell, Dermot Desmond and Michael Nicholson in the stand
Celtic have been asked to clarify details of the Section 9 waiver from the Takeover Panel granted to Dermot Desmond in 2005.
Desmond agreed to underwrite that share offer which was likely to take his stake in the club over 29.9%.
When that happens a formal takeover offer has to be made to all shareholders.
Desmond and Celtic wanted to avoid that, a waiver was granted with the Irishman taking his stake in the club to 35%.
Details of the waiver have never been published. It is believed that it would have involved an undertaking not to exert undue influence on the running of the club.
As a PLC Celtic have a number of obligations that they must comply with.
The most obvious are publishing an Annual Report, publishing Interim Accounts for the half year and staging an AGM.
GOVERNANCE IN THE SPOTLIGHT
The rights of all shareholders is critical. The club must be run in the interests of all shareholders, reflecting their views and protecting their interests.
Various Celtic managers have commented on their dealings with Desmond.
Over the last year Martin O’Neill has discussed various conversations with Desmond, when asked about the businessman he often refers to the Celtic owner.
Now, Celtic Supporters Limited, who have the support of the Board for a Resolution at the 2026 AGM have requested details of the waiver and how it has been observed.
Crucially a reply is required before the AGM which will be held on December 1.
CSL’s solicitors have written to Celtic plc.
Under Rule 9 of the Takeover Code, anyone whose holding passes 30% normally has to offer to buy out every other shareholder. In 2005, during Celtic’s share offers, the Takeover Panel waived that requirement, and an undertaking is understood to have been given by Dermot Desmond and/or Line Nominees Limited. The 2005 offer document said the business would continue in substantially the same manner, with no major changes.
That was 21 years ago.
On the 16th November our solicitors, Macdonald Henderson, asked the board to confirm:
– Whether the undertaking is still in force
– Whether it has been changed since 2005
– What its terms say about governance and the protection of minority shareholders
– How the board makes sure it is being metThis is a request for clarification, not an accusation. We make no allegation that anyone has breached anything.
We have asked for a reply within 14 days, before the AGM on the 1st December. Every shareholder also has the right to ask the Takeover Panel for its view.
You own part of this club. You’re entitled to know the terms it runs under.
https://t.co/WdKTtzemBW
— Celtic Supporters Ltd (@celticCSL) November 17, 2026
INSTANTLY THE CELTIC BOARD ARE IN A CATCH 22 POSITION
Do they own up that they haven’t complied with Section 9 or claim that all is hunky-dory.
With their own evidence and the reply from the board CSL will present their case to the Takeover Panel to review.
Nicholson and McKay have their professional credentials on the line here. One is a lawyer, the other an accountant. They have two weeks to decide how to respond. Their reputations are on the line.
Compliance is the first duty of a Director. It isn’t about selfies with Rod Stewart and sneering at the commoners paying your bloated salaries, bonuses and pension contributions.
Celtic Supporters Limited have certainly introduced fresh thinking to the management and governance of Celtic.
Desmond’s presence and apparent control has just been accepted as the way things are at Celtic.
Now the pressure is on every board member to demonstrate that they are complying with the 2005 waiver. There is no shortage of evidence to the contrary.
Beyond that it is all unknown territory. A range of sanctions are available if the terms of the Section 9 waiver haven’t been complied with.
Outsiders such as Charlie Methven have stated that Celtic have a low market capitalisation for a company of their size, debt free and making substantial Corporation Tax payments on profits from two of the last three years.
@turnsandtwists Time will tell. We will take this one step at a time.
— Celtic Supporters Ltd (@celticCSL) November 17, 2026
