23rd May 2026; Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland; Scottish Cup Final Football, Celtic versus Dunfermline; Celtic board of directors
Matthew Lindsay of the Herald has found himself in the unexpected role of City/Finance Expert.
Not Manchester City or Brechin City but the City of London, high finance and investments. Shareholdings and the Takeover Panel.
It is quite a leap for the Chief Football Writer at the Herald.
Lindsay also shares his expert views and analysis with the Glasgow Times, Celtic Way and Rangers Review. The Newsquest titles edited by Jonny McFarlane.
Like Lindsay, big Jonny isn’t known for his deep intellect or gasp of investment matters.
Saturday’s Herald set out to explain that the possibility of an investigation from the Takeover Panel into Dermot Desmond’s influence on Celtic won’t amount to anything. Nothing to see here, run along everyone. who fancies promises of big signings in the January transfer window?
That prospect of a Takeover Panel investigation was raised on Monday when Celtic Supporters Limited instructed law firm Macdonald Henderson to request information on the 2005 undertaking from Desmond as his shareholding in Celtic went above 29.9%.
What guarantees were given remains unknown.
As shareholders CSL have made an enquiry that the Section 9 waiver has been complied with and remains in place.
Lindsay has gathered a lot of evidence.
He has quoted from the CSL Twitter account and an appearance from Duncan Smillie on the Let Me Be Frank podcast.
Lindsay has tracked down someone that worked for two years as an assistant secretary for the Takeover Panel.
Strangely Lindsay opted against contacting CSL about his ‘deep dive’ into this issue.
How unusual.
WHAT IS THE AGENDA OF THE HERALD?
As recently as February 2025 Lindsay was quoting from David Low on shares, finance and ownership issues.
Low is regularly featured in The Herald but for this in-depth investigation Lindsay decided not to contact Low or anyone from CSL.
Lindsay and The Herald opted to act like the Celtic board. Say nothing, do nothing and hope that everyone will forget.
It is almost as if The Herald had been presented with the entire story and didn’t want to explain anything about their ‘quality journalism’ and engagement with their digital audience.
Interesting, the journalist and newspaper sought out someone from the independent regulator, yet didn’t ask anyone at CSL for their thoughts or comments on this….its not a fair and balanced article if you only have one side of the story.
Why would anyone expect fair and balanced, when compliant is the path to keeping your name off Santa Desmond’s “Naughty List”
FYI, given this ex secretary to the independent regulator, has no insight as to our plan, our evidence or our legal opinion, I’d love to know how they managed to form their opinion…….
— Celtic Supporters Ltd (@celticCSL) November 21, 2026
Lindsay chose not to reply.
He has been challenged on his blockbuster exclusive and left the story out there No defence offered.
He has quoted from the CSL Twitter account but opted out of online engagement with them. Not a good look.
Let’s try and get an answer on here, we tried the @heraldscotland with no success….
Interesting, the journalist and newspaper sought out someone from the independent regulator, yet didn’t ask anyone at CSL for their thoughts or comments on this….its not a fair and balanced article if you only have one side of the story.
Why would anyone expect fair and balanced, when compliant is the path to keeping your name off Santa Desmond’s “Naughty List”
FYI, given this ex secretary to the independent regulator, has no insight as to our plan, our evidence or our legal opinion, I’d love to know how they managed to form their opinion…….
— Celtic Supporters Ltd (@celticCSL) November 21, 2026
Two Newsquest titles falling silent.
These days journalism is about engagement. Connecting with readers/subscribers, generating an audience.
On this story The Herald has opted out.
To get to the heart of the story Lindsay dug deep into his contact book of financial experts:
Max Mittasch, a mergers and acquisitions partner at London-based law firm Macfarlanes, was an assistant secretary at the Takeover Panel between 2020 and 2022.
He regulated more than 300 transactions, including the offers for Morrisons, Meggitt, William Hill and Signature Aviation, during his secondment and is familiar with how the oversight body operates.
What an incredible workload. 150 transactions a year, that works out at more than three a week assuming that Mittasch was given some annual leave and public holidays
Discussing a possible investigation from the Takeover Panel Mittasch told The Herald:
The first step would be the panel starting an investigation. They have wide-ranging powers and can compel people to supply documents and answer questions.
If they then found that somebody had breached the Takeover Code in such a way that a mandatory offer would have been required to be made to the other shareholders, they can ultimately require that person to make that offer. That is what happened with Rangers not so long ago.
That is an extreme sanction. There are other more minor sanctions, such as private censures and public censures. But the ultimate sanction is requiring a person to make a mandatory offer.
THE COLD SHOULDER FEAR FOR CELTIC DIRECTORS
Strangely there is no mention of being cold shouldered, that would come from a public censure.
For Michael Nicholson and Chris McKay that would be very bad news. Presumably as a lawyer and solicitor they value their membership of professional bodies.
If Desmond was overstepping the mark in relation to the Section 9 waiver they were duty bound to step in.
The favoured ‘I didn’t know’ excuse doesn’t stack up. With their huge salaries comes responsibility and obligations.
Mittasch concluded with some wooly, reassuring words for the Celtic board although he hasn’t a clue about the terms of the 2005 deal with the Takeover Panel:
Whatever was said at the time (of the 2005 share issue) would only have been valid for a certain period of time, say for 12 months. I’d be surprised if a commitment that was given 21 years ago is still valid.
If somebody stated they were going to do or not do certain things within a 12-month period and then did something different, then, yes, the Takeover Panel would look at that.
But if three, four, five years down the line, somebody who has increased their shareholding from 25 per cent to 35 per cent tries to exert undue influence on the company, I’m not sure the Takeover Panel would necessarily be the right regulator to complain to about that.
It is not really within their remit anymore. They are there to enforce the Takeover Code and the rules within it. If a commitment was given for 12 months and everything was complied with during that period, then that is fine. That should be, in theory, where things end for the Takeover Panel.
If other things happen, if a major shareholder is trying to control the company and other shareholders find that offensive, then you look to the courts instead of the Takeover Panel.
A shareholder exerting influence over a company? That’s not really a matter for the Takeover Panel. That just happens as a result of somebody having a lot of voting rights. Therefore the regulator won’t get involved.
So zero detail.
Celtic’s stance will be known by December 1, the date of the 2026 AGM.
Not answering the request from CSL won’t be a good look.
The other two options are where it gets interesting.
Admitting that the 2005 waiver has been broken would be bad news for everyone on the Celtic board, seriously bad.
If the terms set out in 2005 have been complied with then Nicholson, Wilson and McKay will have some detailed questions to answer when they hear from the Takeover Panel.
Not the type of questions that you can deflect to a friendly publisher to reassure everyone that all is well at the self-declared brilliantly managed football club.

