9th September 2026; McDiarmid Park, Perth, Scotland: Scottish Premiership Football, St Johnstone versus Celtic; Referee Matthew MacDermid
Matthew MacDermid gave a typically petty and over-bearing display as he refereed Celtic’s 4-1 win over St Mirren.
Like Willie Collum, McDermid is a member of the Lanarkshire Referee Association, the group that dominates Scottish refereeing.
MacDermid seems to model his entire approach to football on Collum.
The referee is the star of the show, players are an inconvenient sideshow, to be treated with contempt.
Celtic had two ‘goals’ disallowed in the first half.
The first, a header from Camilo Duran from a Kieran Tierney cross was clearly offside. The assistant referee called it correctly.
The second remains a mystery, no VAR lines were produced on a marginal decision as Duran passed the ball forward to Jota.
MACDERMID JUST ISN’T ANY GOOD AT THE JOB
MacDermid revelled in the drama with the ‘goals’ disallowed. The attention.
Like all aspiring Scottish referees he knows how to slow Celtic down, playing the Disadvantage Rule expertly.
@Highland__paddy How this guy has a FIFA badge is beyond me. His incompetence is astonishing. If he is the best of whats coming through god help the game here.
— Candh na daoine ???????????? (@kennybhoy21) November 21, 2026
Everyone good a full warning what not to do. Cillian Phillips the taker, Celtic goalkeeper Sam Johnstone and others such as Joel van den Berg standing on the 18 yard line.
The players are full time professionals.
They know the Laws of the Game, they don’t need lectures from a jumped up no-mark looking to impose his authority. To climb the lucrative refereeing ladder.
MacDermid has had a nightmare season, regularly in the spotlight with his bizarre take on the Laws of the Game.
There were no major decisions or errors in Celtic’s win. Just the usual stream of frustrating and annoying decisions.
In defence of MacDermid the evidence suggests that he is just genuinely bad at the job rather than biased. Refereeing is easy money rather than a mission or passion.
With Collum the example for all that are looking for easy part-time money.
@Highland__paddy He was atrocious! He is that bad that you can’t even claim bias! Thats how bad a referee he his.
— Stewart Millar (@beebhoy7) November 21, 2026
