3rd June 2023; Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland: Scottish Cup Football Final, Celtic versus Inverness Caledonian Thistle; Peter Lawwell, Dermot Desmond and Michael Nicholson in the stand
Duncan Smillie has questioned the motives of Dermot Desmond at Celtic.
Smillie is one of the four directors in Celtic Supporters Limited which is questioning the governance of the club.
On Monday they made a very important step by writing to Celtic to question the Section 9 waiver that the club was granted in 2005, allowing Desmond to extend his shareholding beyond 29.9% without having to make a formal takeover bid.
Certain conditions would have been attached to that decision.
It is assumed that not exerting ‘undue influence’ was one.
CSL has written to Celtic simply asking if the club has complied with the waiver granted by the Takeover Panel.
Crucially they have asked Celtic to respond by November 30. A 14 day period that ends the day before the AGM.
There appears to be lots of evidence to suggest that Desmond is one of the key decision managers.
THE ROLE AND INFLUENCE OF DESMOND ON CELTIC
He has been name checked by managers from Gordon Strachan through to Ange Postecoglou and Brendan Rodgers. Neil Lennon refers to the businessman in reverential tones as Mr Desmond, asked about Desmond and Martin O’Neill will respond by referencing the owner.
Almost nothing is known about Desmond and his Celtic interest. He has never sat down to a media conference in a Celtic capacity, an interview surfaces every couple of years which seems to entirely focus on domestic trophy wins.
Ahead of the December 1 AGM, CSL have raised their profile.
Smillie took part in a Q and A with Ryan McDonald of the Daily Record.
QUESTION: If you had one question, what would you ask Dermot Desmond?
Smille:
Why are you punishing Celtic fans? Where do you see the end game for this? Because it doesn’t look like you have the best interests of Celtic at hand.
Why don’t you step aside and let somebody else that’s got the ambition, and that can match the ambitions of the fans and the club? Because clearly you don’t have that. He’s got people in there that do exactly what they’re told, over-promoted execs and non-execs. Non-execs have been there five, 10, 15, 20 years. You can no longer be considered independent if you’ve been sat on a board for 20 years. He likes to say that he owns Celtic. He doesn’t own Celtic. He has control of the club, which he shouldn’t have.
The Daily Record Q and A didn’t mention the Takeover Panel or the Section 9 waiver granted to Celtic over the 2005 share issue.
That took Desmond’s stake above 29.9% without him having to make an offer for the remaining shares.
Clearly McDonald will be aware of that issue, he also has media access to Celtic including boozy nights out in Albufeira.
Perhaps he could contact his Celtic insiders for their reaction to the CSL request over whether the club has complied with the terms of the Takeover Panel waiver?
That would be much more of a story than passing on a vague pledge to buy a defensive midfielder in January.

