Hugh Dallas has admitted that it has been a disappointing season with disappointing decisions that he has been uncomfortable with.
Predictably the man that has developed and groomed the current batch of referee’s hasn’t highlighted any specific incidents and has, true to form, reached out for the honest mistakes line. As if there could ever be any other possibility.
Once again over the weekend we witnessed amazing inconsistencies, Celtic players being booked for kicking the ball away and an Aberdeen player able to leave the field of play, celebrate with supporters and take his shirt off without referee Iain Brines reaching for a card.
No Celtic supporter has any real complaint about Stevie MacLean’s actions, if he had ran towards the Celtic support, Adebayor-style, it would have been a different story.
He scored his goal, earned his team a point and deserves the right to celebrate. Just like Georgios Samaras at St Johnstone or Morten Rasmussen against Hamilton.
Or Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink at Inverness three years ago which left Brines with no option but to yellow card and send the Dutchman off.
Or Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink at Inverness three years ago which left Brines with no option but to yellow card and send the Dutchman off.
That day Brines applied the letter of the law, presumably on Saturday he used the 18th law of the game Common Sense which covers up for refs disobeying the laws of the game.
There has been much more than goal celebrations for Celtic supporters to get concerned with this season, aside from the obvious deficiencies evident in the team.
Clear cut penalty decisions were denied early in the season against Dundee United, Hearts and Rangers which finally saw Dallas issue a second hand apology on behalf of Craig Thompson who admitted to one wrong penalty call in the October 4 Rangers-Celtic game.
Interestingly in today’s admission Dallas claims: “the first question we always ask is: ‘Why?’ In order to understand the reason behind it we need to hear the reason.”
Strangely enough no explanation was ever offered for Thompson’s failure to see David Weir’s foul on Shaun Maloney, human error we can assume.
Dallas met with SPL managers at Hampden last Friday and finally admitted that it hasn’t been a season to be proud of from the countries referees but again opted out of giving specific instances or reasons for the error-strewn season.
He explained: “If I am being honest, I would say this has been a disappointing season with some disappointing decisions, which I wish we didn’t have to analyse and talk about.
“We examine these in detail at the Referee Development Department and the first question we always ask is: ‘Why?’ In order to understand the reason behind it we need to hear the reason.
“Obviously there have been incidents this season I have been uncomfortable with. I am not going to sit here and pretend mistakes have not been made but it is how the referees learn from these that is important.”
Perhaps publically admitting to mistakes being made by referees and demoting them from SPL matches would be a good start in ensuring stronger decisions are made and referees who repeatedly fail to apply the laws of the game are removed from the higher profile matches.
That may initially effect referees, but equally, younger promising referees with a flair from the game, not necessarily coming through from the professions, may be encouraged if they see a clear route to the top based on ability and decision making rather than being a favourite of the games rulers.
Dallas’s comments are clearly aimed at supporters starting to air their concerns and gathering evidence of repeated mistakes from referees.
Whether he has addressed his officials and issued clear guidelines on fairly trivial matters like post-goal celebrations remains to be seen.
With a Rangers-Celtic game looming less than two weeks away the SFA could do without their officials being ridiculed with the eyes of the world looking in via Sky Sports.
Thompson and Steve Conroy have both made major mistakes in these fixtures already this season, a repeat of that next Sunday will confirm today’s statement from Dallas as having all the conviction of a political manifesto.
As the Champions League resumes this week we will see increasing numbers of younger, fitter, dedicated officials not afraid of making big decisions.
None of them will be Scottish.
Another great article Joe.
The beaks at the SFA are laughing at every last one of us, people talk about the economic climate turning fans away.
Cheating refs and official whitewashes are now becoming so tedious that many fans have had enough.
The quicker a European or UK league is adopted the quicker we can get rid of the corrupt blazers who are killing Scottish football.
Everyone knows that Rangers are getting every decision at the moment. Plenty of incidents in their last two games that Motherwell & Hibs fans will quickly tell you about has be the norm form day one this season.
Time to Go.
http://itcantbeparanoia.blogspot.com/
I'd be careful about some of those comments anon.
A stronger case can be made when incidents are highlighted rationally and compared.
Proving anything other than repeated poor decision making will never happen.
Getting officials to be accountable, mistakes being admitted to and not excused would go a long way towards improving the standards of officials coming through and being given the high profile matches.
They can keep going on apologising but they are laughing while theya re apologising, they have done what has been expected of them.
On the bookings Willie the Collum was the referee who booked Samras at St Johnstone tow weeks ago, the next week Aberdeen scored a late equaliser away to Raith Rovers. Scotrer ran into crowd, crowd surge, stewards shoved about etc. Willie the Collum was also the referee, no bookings given.
Celtic should have made a complaint after the Motherwell away game, after we won despite the referees best efforts.
Complaining now just looks like excuses.
So of course, as usual only Celtic are on the bad end of decisions, is thsat your 'theory'?
Have you watched any other team this year?
Referees are having a bad year of that there is no doubt but your claims of paranioa are tiresome.
Also why did you illustrate your post with a picture of one decision that was right (Fortune's foul on McGregor – as verified by TV evidence form Pat Nevim amonst others).
>>>Everyone knows that Rangers are getting every decision at the moment.<<< Thats why they didn't get the penalty when Weir was pulled down in the box at 0-0 on Sunday then? Seriously is it only controversial when it goes against your wishes?
You're a laughable lot.
the worrying thing about the bias in these descions is the fact that rangers are so willing to accept them then moan about one or two that go against them over a season but they are the people after all
get a life your team is murder 10 pts 21 goals celtic are bad
david…..
what you say may be true….
still doesn't mean we aren't cheated more than your club is.
you call it paranoia……
we call it the facts….
now move on and bore somebody else please.
We all know this is a poor Celtic side but we have all seen too many dodgy decisions this season, a few websites and blogs are detailing them match by match.
The fact that Rangers haven't won a match refereed by a non Scot in almost two years says a lot, as does the fact that in 50 years of European competition they lag behind Dundee United and Dundee in terms of achievement